Skip to Content
Top

Howard Luke's Instincts, the Instagram Hottie's Saga Concludes, and Introducing Mike Carroll's $50,000 Knockout

Serving Families Throughout Honolulu
|

Attorney Michael Carroll dismantled the State’s NCIC trap to wipe out a $50,000 bail forfeiture. 

  • Images are created using Google’s FLOW image creator (AI) 

Roughly twenty years ago, I was sitting in District Court watching prime Howard Luke represent a client on a serious felony charge. I wasn't sophisticated enough back then to grasp every statutory nuance playing out on the floor, yet what happened next burned itself into my memory. Without filing a single written motion, Mr. Luke stood up, made an oral motion to dismiss on procedural grounds, and walked away with an immediate dismissal. The case was never recharged.

That lightning-fast victory taught me a lesson that has guided my twenty-plus years in the arena: a great attorney doesn’t just memorize the law—like Howard Luke, they possess the killer instinct to know the exact moment to pull the trigger.

Which brings us to the conclusion of our multipart series on the "Instagram Hottie"—and a masterclass in courtroom timing from an unexpected heavyweight.

The Instagram Hottie Finale: Zero Consequences and a Missed Opportunity

After multiple missed appearances and hundreds of hours of relentless fugitive recovery work by her bail agent, the Instagram Hottie finally appeared for sentencing. Following plenty of twists and turns, she walked out with probation—specifically, a Deferred Acceptance of Guilty Plea (DAG)—and faced zero repercussions for bolting from the jurisdiction without court permission, skipping court multiple times, and somehow didn't once get her bail raised despite absolutely deserving so based on violations of conditions of release.

While I’m glad the bond issue got resolved, watching a related forfeiture hearing in that saga left me seething in the gallery.

In open court, the Prosecutor’s Office brazenly admitted they refused to enter her bench warrant into the National Crime Information Center (NCIC) database—despite being handed an indisputable electronic paper trail showing her jet-setting to luxury resorts in Florida, dining at Michelin-star restaurants, and literally geotagging her own whereabouts on Instagram while a bench warrant sat active for her arrest.

What really grinds my gears wasn't just the State’s apathy; it was seeing a less-experienced bail agent stand there unaware that the prosecutor’s refusal to enter an NCIC warrant when given material evidence showing the fugitive was out of state constitutes a near-indisputable claim for bond exoneration.

The Disjunctive: How Prosecutors Manufacture "Good Cause"

Under Hawaiʻi bail law (State v. Camara and HRS § 804-51), the standard for establishing "good cause" to set aside a forfeiture is written as a disjunctive—my favorite word in the legal lexicon, famously underscored by Hawaiʻi Supreme Court Associate Justice Todd Eddins (shoutout to Justice Eddins on his recent induction into the Rock for Justice Hall of Fame).

A disjunctive ("or") means a surety extinguishes forfeiture liability in not just one way, but multiple independent ways:

  1. Surrender: Returning the defendant into custody (the most ironclad route).
  2. Satisfactory Reason (Contractual Impossibility): Showing a valid, unavoidable reason why the defendant could not be produced.

When a defendant flees to the mainland, a local Hawaiʻi bench warrant has zero legal teeth outside the islands. A bail agent cannot lawfully detain someone in another state or drag them through a federal TSA checkpoint onto a commercial flight without: (1) the process literally being the textbook definition of kidnapping, and (2) without the unified standards of extradition being followed, even law enforcement cannot legally extradite a fugitive from one state to another without the legal requirements met for extradition. 

Let's not forget that even those caught on NCIC warrants in other jurisdictions still have to go through court appearances to determine the application of Governor's warrants, and/or signed waivers of extradition—typically within 30 to 90 days—just to legally transport a fugitive from one state to another. How any government agency expects a bail agent to magically snap their fingers and have that entire process done to the letter of the law is beyond sophomoric—it's completely divorced from reality. 

By ignoring a bail agent's documented proof of a fugitive’s mainland location and refusing to enter the warrant into the NCIC, the Prosecutor’s Office becomes the sole impediment blocking the defendant's surrender. They literally manufacture the surety's "good cause" through their own bureaucratic neglect. Over the last two decades, I have personally seen several forfeitures set aside on this exact issue.

Giving Flowers to Michael C. Carroll: A $50,000 Knockout

While heavyweights like Bill Harrison, Keith Kiuchi, and newcomer to the scene, appellate attorney Benjamin Lowenthal, are household names in the surety defense game, I want to give major flowers to Michael C. Carroll—a partner at the powerhouse Honolulu litigation firm Lung Rose Voss & Wagnild.

Michael C. Carroll has been recognized in publications like Best Lawyers in real estate litigation and construction law, making him a relatively new face in the world of surety bail law. But given his background in construction law—where insurance and surety agreements are standard—it's not surprising that he would immediately grasp the criminal version of surety law, specifically bail bond contracts. When he stepped into the arena on behalf of Shaka Bail LLC in State v. Michael Perreira Thompson III, he delivered an absolute clinic—and boy, was the fact pattern a doozy:

  • The Setup: After pleading guilty to felony “theft in the first degree” and “unauthorized control of a propelled vehicle” charges and skipping his April 2026 sentencing, defendant Perreira-Thompson fled to Georgia, leaving Shaka Bail on the hook for a $50,000 forfeiture.
  • The Recovery Work: Shaka Bail owner retained veteran recovery agent Tony Hill, who tracked down Thompson in Georgia. The surety offered to pay 100% of the extradition costs if granted NCIC entry.
  • The State's Blockade: Both the Attorney General and City Prosecutor’s office (citing undisclosed "internal criteria") flatly refused to enter the felony warrant into the NCIC.
  • The Punchline: Because Hawaiʻi wouldn't put him in the NCIC, Perreira-Thompson was released after being arrested by the Locust Grove Police Department (Georgia) on the charge of “driving while unlicensed.”

Carroll didn't let the State get away with talking in circles. He filed a razor-sharp Supplemental Memorandum dismantling the State’s excuses, proving under Camara and distinguishing State v. Flores that Shaka Bail had done everything humanly possible and was thwarted purely by the State's refusal to act. On August 13, 2026, Circuit Court Judge, The Honorable Rowena Somerville granted the motion, vacating the $50,000 forfeiture judgment and discharging Shaka Bail completely.

Logically and in the basic interest of justice, the government cannot have it both ways. Expecting a bail agency to pay a $50,000 forfeiture while denying them the very warrant required to bring the fugitive back is a complete contradiction.

The Bottom Line: Instinct, Timing, and Accountability

From Howard Luke standing up in District Court twenty years ago to catch the State sleeping on procedure, to the Instagram Hottie skating on a DAG while prosecutors ignored her geotagged Florida vacation, to Michael Carroll stepping outside his usual practice area to hand the State a $50,000 loss in Circuit Court—the thread connecting them all is simple: the law is only as powerful as the advocate bold enough to enforce it at the exact right moment.

When the government drops the ball, hides behind secret "internal criteria," and still tries to stick private citizens and sureties with the bill, it takes sharp instincts and fearless advocacy to call their bluff. Kudos to Mike Carroll for stepping into the ring and reminding the State that accountability runs both ways.

— Jail Mail Nick